As a startup founder, one of the most common ways to raise early-stage capital is through convertible notes. Convertible notes are a form of debt financing that allows startups to raise funds from investors with the promise of converting the debt into equity at a later date, usually during a future financing round or when certain trigger events occur. Convertible notes have become a popular tool for early-stage funding due to their flexibility and simplicity, but they can also be complex instruments with various negotiation points. In this article, we will explore the key features of convertible notes, why they are necessary, the key negotiation points, and other relevant details that startup founders need to know.
Need a Convertible Note Term Sheet Template?
Instant Download Now Available
Key Features of Convertible Notes
- Debt Instrument: Convertible notes are a form of debt instrument, meaning that the startup borrows money from investors and promises to repay the principal and interest at a later date. However, unlike traditional debt, convertible notes are designed to convert into equity instead of being repaid in cash. This makes them unique and suitable for early-stage startups that may not have the cash flow to service traditional debt.
- Conversion Feature: The conversion feature is the key element of convertible notes. It allows the debt to convert into equity at a later date, usually during a future financing round or when certain trigger events occur, such as a sale of the company or an initial public offering (IPO). The conversion rate is typically determined based on the terms negotiated between the startup and the investor, and it can be fixed or variable, depending on the terms of the convertible note.
- Interest Rate: Convertible notes may also accrue interest at a specified rate, which is typically lower than market rates for traditional debt. The interest accrues on the principal amount of the note and may be paid in cash at maturity or converted into equity along with the principal amount upon conversion.
- Maturity Date: The maturity date is the date when the convertible note becomes due and payable if it has not been converted into equity before then. The maturity date is typically set at a certain number of years from the date of issuance of the convertible note, and it can be extended or amended through negotiations between the startup and the investor.
- Valuation Cap: The valuation cap is a feature of convertible notes that sets a maximum valuation at which the notes can convert into equity. If the valuation of the startup at the time of the conversion is higher than the valuation cap, the notes will convert into equity based on the valuation cap, allowing the noteholders to benefit from the lower valuation.
- Discount Rate: The discount rate is another feature of convertible notes that provides investors with a discount on the price per share of equity that they would receive upon conversion. The discount rate is typically negotiated between the startup and the investor and is applied to the price per share of equity in the next financing round or trigger event, allowing the noteholders to benefit from a lower price per share.
Why Convertible Notes are Necessary
Convertible notes are commonly used by startups for several reasons:
- Simplicity and Speed: Convertible notes are relatively simple and quick to set up compared to other forms of financing, such as equity rounds or traditional debt. They do not require a valuation of the startup, which can be challenging at early stages when the valuation may be uncertain or subject to change. Convertible notes also do not require setting a price per share, which can be a complex negotiation point in equity rounds. This simplicity and speed make convertible notes an attractive option for startups that need to raise funds quickly and with minimal legal and administrative complexity.
- Flexibility: Convertible notes are flexible in terms of their conversion feature, allowing startups to defer the determination of the valuation and the price per share until a future financing round or trigger event. This flexibility is particularly useful for early-stage startups that may not have a clear understanding of their valuation or future financing needs. It also allows startups to avoid dilution of existing shareholders at the time of the convertible note financing, as the conversion of the notes into equity usually occurs in a future financing round with a new set of investors.
- Investor Appeal: Convertible notes can be attractive to investors as they provide an opportunity to invest in startups at an earlier stage without having to negotiate a valuation or a price per share. Investors can benefit from the potential upside of the startup’s future equity appreciation, as the notes convert into equity at a later date when the valuation may be higher. Additionally, the valuation cap and discount rate features of convertible notes can provide investors with additional upside potential and incentives to invest.
Key Negotiation Points in Convertible Notes
While convertible notes offer simplicity and flexibility, there are several key negotiation points that startup founders should be aware of when issuing convertible notes:
- Conversion Terms: The conversion terms of the convertible notes are critical and should be carefully negotiated. This includes the conversion rate, which determines the number of shares that the convertible notes will convert into at the time of conversion, and whether the conversion rate is fixed or variable. The valuation cap and discount rate, if applicable, should also be negotiated, as they can impact the conversion price and dilution for existing shareholders. Startups should carefully consider the potential impact of these conversion terms on their capitalization table and future financing rounds.
- Interest Rate and Maturity Date: The interest rate and maturity date of the convertible notes are also important negotiation points. The interest rate should be reasonable and reflective of market rates for similar early-stage financing. The maturity date should provide sufficient time for the startup to achieve significant milestones or secure a future financing round before the notes become due and payable. Startups should be cautious about setting a short maturity date that may result in financial pressure if the notes are not converted or repaid by the maturity date.
- Rights and Protections for Investors: Convertible notes may include additional rights and protections for investors, such as anti-dilution provisions, information rights, and voting rights. Anti-dilution provisions protect investors from dilution in the event of a down round, while information rights provide investors with access to the startup’s financial and operational information. Voting rights may grant investors the ability to vote on certain matters related to the company’s operations or future financing rounds. These additional rights and protections should be carefully considered and negotiated, as they can impact the startup’s governance and decision-making.
- Governing Law and Jurisdiction: The governing law and jurisdiction of the convertible notes should also be negotiated. Startups and investors may have different preferences for the governing law and jurisdiction, and this can impact the legal rights and remedies available to both parties in case of a dispute. It’s important to carefully consider and negotiate the governing law and jurisdiction to ensure that it aligns with the startup’s operations and investor’s preferences.
- Repayment Provisions: While most convertible notes are designed to convert into equity, some convertible notes may include repayment provisions that require the startup to repay the principal amount of the notes with interest if a conversion event does not occur by a certain date. Repayment provisions can impact the startup’s cash flow and financial obligations, so it’s important to carefully consider and negotiate the repayment provisions, if included in the convertible notes.
- Information Rights: Information rights are often included in convertible notes, providing investors with access to the startup’s financial and operational information. Startups should carefully consider the scope and frequency of information rights, as providing regular updates and financial information to a large number of note holders can be time-consuming and burdensome. Negotiating the scope and frequency of information rights can help strike a balance between transparency and administrative burden.
- Investor Qualifications: Convertible notes may also include investor qualifications, such as requiring investors to be accredited investors or to comply with certain securities laws or regulations. Startups should be aware of the regulatory requirements and investor qualifications when issuing convertible notes, as failure to comply with these requirements can result in legal and regulatory consequences.
- Exit Rights: Some convertible notes may include exit rights that provide investors with certain rights or preferences in the event of an acquisition or IPO. For example, convertible notes may include provisions that require the notes to be repaid at a certain multiple of the investment amount in the event of an acquisition, or that provide the notes with a preference over other shareholders in the distribution of proceeds in an exit event. These exit rights should be carefully considered and negotiated to ensure that they align with the startup’s long-term goals and exit strategy.
Other Considerations with Convertible Notes
In addition to the key negotiation points mentioned above, there are a few other considerations that startup founders should be aware of when using convertible notes:
- Impact on Capitalization Table: Convertible notes can impact the startup’s capitalization table, as they will convert into equity at a later date. This can result in dilution of existing shareholders, including founders, employees, and other investors. It’s important to carefully consider the impact of convertible notes on the capitalization table and the potential dilution that may occur in future financing rounds.
- Future Financing Rounds: Convertible notes are typically designed to convert into equity in a future financing round or trigger event. Startups should carefully plan for future financing rounds and consider how the convertible notes will impact the terms and structure of those rounds. For example, if a startup plans to raise an equity round shortly after a convertible note financing, the terms of the convertible notes, such as the conversion rate, valuation cap, and discount rate, may impact the terms and valuation of the equity round.
- Legal and Accounting Considerations: While convertible notes are relatively simple compared to other forms of financing, they still involve legal and accounting considerations. Startups should work with experienced legal and accounting professionals to ensure that the convertible notes are properly structured, documented, and accounted for in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.
► Getting Legal Help
AXIS Legal Counsel’s Business and Corporations Practice provides legal advice to numerous businesses with a wide range of business matters. Axis represent small, medium-sized, and large business clients with a wide variety of business and corporate law matters. We represent early-stage companies as well as established businesses on a wide variety of business law matters, ranging from contracts and transactions, intellectual property, labor/employment law, business financing, mergers and acquisitions, real estate, insurance, business succession planning, and general advice and counsel. For information on retaining AXIS Legal Counsel to represent your business in connection with any legal matter, contact [email protected] for a confidential consultation.
► Our Business, Corporate Law and Securities Practice Areas
► Read our Business FAQs
Our FAQs answer the most common issues faced by startups and businesses.
We have an extensive FAQ Library that covers the most common questions we get from businesses, as well as FAQs on recent changes in law affecting businesses .
► Learn About Our Recent Projects
Have we counseled businesses like yours? All the time.
We have represented a variety of business clients in numerous industries across multiple disciplines and practice matters. Here are some of the highlights:
► AS SEEN IN
Our talented legal counsel has been quoted in a number of press outlets, including the following:
► Serving Clients Nationwide and in 22+ Countries Internationally
We represent clients throughout the U.S. and in 22+ countries internationally.